Welcome to OGeek Q&A Community for programmer and developer-Open, Learning and Share
Welcome To Ask or Share your Answers For Others

Categories

0 votes
757 views
in Technique[技术] by (71.8m points)

c# - Fastest way to convert a BigInteger to a decimal (Base 10) string?

Answers So Far

So here is the code breakdown.

//Time: ~7s (linear loop algorithm)
//100,000! (456,574 decimal digits)
BigInteger bigIntVar = computeFactorial(100000);

//The first three here are just for comparison and are not actually Base 10.
bigIntVar.ToBase64String() //Time: 00.001s | Base 64 | Tetrasexagesimal
bigIntVar.ToString("x")    //Time: 00.016s | Base 16 | Hexadecimal
bigIntVar.ToBinaryString() //Time: 00.026s | Base 02 | Binary
bigIntVar.ToQuickString()  //Time: 11.200s | Base 10 | String Version
bigIntVar.ToQuickString()  //Time: 12.500s | Base 10 | StringBuilder Version
bigIntVar.ToString()       //Time: 13.300s | Base 10 | Original

Original Question Stuff

I have spent way to much time on this, so I need your help.

This is for a personal project to compute ginormous factorials (ex. 100,000!)

Here is my code:

using (var stream = new StreamWriter(fileName + ".txt", false))
{
    stream.WriteLine(header);

    var timer = new Stopwatch();    
    timer.Restart();
    //This is the huge BigInteger holding the answer to 100,000!
    stream.WriteLine(saveFactorial.Output.ToString());         
    //Let me be clear: ToString() is directly causing the the 13sec time delay.
    //Not the stream.
    timer.Stop();                   
}

time = (timer.ElapsedMilliseconds / 1000.0).ToString() + "s"; 

MessageBox.Show(time);

On 100,000! is takes about 7sec on my machine to compute (linear loop algorithm).

Yet with this standard IO code it takes 13sec to save.

So in other words, it takes longer to save the work than it does to modestly compute it.

So I thought maybe I could use:

BigInteger.ToByteArray();

Although this runs extremely fast, I couldn't figure out how to save it to readable text.

You can use the above method to write the binary string to a text file with this self-made extension:

ToBinaryString

//Usage: string bigIntBinary = bigIntVar.ToBinaryString();
public static string ToBinaryString(this BigInteger source)
{
    //If you lookup the ToByteArray() method...
    //It actually stores the bytes in reverse order.
    var bigIntBytes = source.ToByteArray().Reverse();

    StringBuilder bigIntBinary = new StringBuilder();

    foreach (var bigIntByte in bigIntBytes)
    {
       bigIntBinary.Append(Convert.ToString(bigIntByte, 2).PadLeft(8, '0'));
    }

    return bigIntBinary.ToString();
}

ToBase64String

    ////Usage: string bigIntBase64 = bigIntVar.ToBase64String();
    public static string ToBase64String(this BigInteger source)
    {
        var bigIntBytes = source.ToByteArray().Reverse().ToArray();

        return Convert.ToBase64String(bigIntBytes);
    }

I also tried the math way (mod 10, etc...) to get each digit, but that takes a TON more time that ToString().

What am I doing wrong here?


This code is what I came up with based on the answer below. This is faster than ToString(), but only by a couple seconds.

ToQuickString

//Usage: string bigIntString = bigIntVar.ToQuickString()
public static String ToQuickString(this BigInteger source)
{
    powersOfTen = new List<BigInteger>();

    powersOfTen.Add(1);

    for (BigInteger i = 10; i < source; i *= i)
    {
        powersOfTen.Add(i);
    }

    return BuildString(source, powersOfTen.Count - 1).ToString().TrimStart('0');
}

private static List<BigInteger> powersOfTen;

private static string BuildString(BigInteger n, int m)
{
    if (m == 0)
        return n.ToString();

    BigInteger remainder;
    BigInteger quotient = BigInteger.DivRem(n, powersOfTen[m], out remainder);

    return BuildString(quotient, m - 1) + BuildString(remainder, m - 1);
}
See Question&Answers more detail:os

与恶龙缠斗过久,自身亦成为恶龙;凝视深渊过久,深渊将回以凝视…
Welcome To Ask or Share your Answers For Others

1 Reply

0 votes
by (71.8m points)

First I'd calculate all numbers of the form 10^(2^m) smaller than n. Then I'd use DivRem with the largest of these to split the problem into two subproblems. Repeat that recursively until you're down to individual digits.

var powersOfTen=new List<BigInteger>();
powersOfTen.Add(1);
for(BigInteger i=10;i<n;i=i*i)
  powersOfTen.Add(i);

string ToString(BigInteger n, int m)
{
  if(m==0)
    return n.ToString();
  quotient = DivRem(n,powersOfTen[m], remainder)
  return ToString(quotient, m-1)+ToString(remainder, m-1)
}

You can also optimize out the string concatenation entirely by directly writing into a character array.


Alternatively you could consider using base 1000'000'000 during all the calculations. That way you don't need the base conversion in the end at all. That's probably much faster for factorial calculation.

List<int> multiply(List<int> f1, int f2)
{
  int carry=0;
  for(int i=0;i<f1.Count;i++)
  {
    var product=(Int64)f1[i]*(Int64)f2;
    carry=product/1000000000;
    result.Add(product%1000000000);
  }
  if(carry!=0)
    result.Add(carry);
}

Now conversion to a base 10 string is trivial and cheap.


与恶龙缠斗过久,自身亦成为恶龙;凝视深渊过久,深渊将回以凝视…
OGeek|极客中国-欢迎来到极客的世界,一个免费开放的程序员编程交流平台!开放,进步,分享!让技术改变生活,让极客改变未来! Welcome to OGeek Q&A Community for programmer and developer-Open, Learning and Share
Click Here to Ask a Question

...