javascript - reactjs this.refs vs document.getElementById

Question

If I have just a basic forms, should I still this.refs or just go with document.getElementById?

By basic I mean something like:

export default class ForgetPasswordComponent extends React.Component {
  constructor(props) {
    super(props);

    this.handleSendEmail = this.handleSendEmail.bind(this);
  }

  handleSendEmail(e) {
    e.preventDefault();

    // this.refs.email.value
    // document.getElementById('email').value
  }

  render() {
    <form onSubmit={this.handleSendEmail}>
      <input id="email" ref="email" type="text" />
      <input type="submit" />
    </form>
  }
}

Is there a downside into using one over the other?

question from:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/37273876/reactjs-this-refs-vs-document-getelementbyid

Answer 1

In general, refs is better than document.getElementById, because it is more in line with the rest of your react code.

In react, every component class can have multiple component instances.
And as @Isuru points out in comments: using id is dangerous, because react does not prevent you to have multiple forms on 1 page, and then your DOM contains multiple inputs with same ID. And that is not allowed.

Another advantage to using refs, is that by design, you can only access the refs in the context where you define it. This forces you to use props and state (and possibly stores) if you need to access info outside of this context.
And this an advantage, because there is less/ no chance of you breaking your unidirectional data flow, which would make your code less manageable.

NB: In almost all cases, refs can be avoided altogether. It is a design principle for Netflix to use no refs, ever, as explained by Steve McGuire (Senior User Interface Engineer at Netflix) in this video from reactjs conf 2016 (9:58m into the video).
In your case, this would mean putting the email-input value in state of the form, add on onChange handler, and use the state value in the submit event.