.net - How do I test an async method with NUnit (or possibly with another framework)?

Question

I have an ASP.NET Web API application, with an ApiController that features asynchronous methods, returning Task<> objects and marked with the async keyword.

public class MyApiController : ApiController
{
    public async Task<MyData> GetDataById(string id)
    {
        ...
    }
}

How can I write NUnit tests for the ApiController's asynchronous methods? If I need to use another testing framework I'm open for that too. I'm fairly new to .NET unit testing in general, so I'm interested in learning best practices.

Answer 1

As of today (7/2/2014) async testing is supported by:

• xUnit: with async methods that return a Task (since 1.9)
• MSTest: with async methods that return a Task (since VS 2012)
• NUnit: with async methods that return a Task, or even, that return void, since 2.6.2. Since 3.0 th option to return void is not supported, as the doc of the analyzer error NUnit1012 The async test method must have a non-void return type explains.

In the first two frameworks, the test method must have this signature:

[TestMethod]
public async Task MyTestMethod()
{
   ...
   var result = await objectUnderTest.TestedAsyncMethod(...);
   // Make assertions
}

NUnit v2.6.2+ (but before 3.0), apart from that signature, supports this one:

public async void MyTestMethod()

Of course, inside any of these test methods you can use await to call and wait on asynchronous methods.

If you're using a testing framework that doesn't support async test methods, then, the only way to do it, is to call the async method and wait until it finishes running using any of the usual ways: await, reading the Result property of the Task<T> returned by an async method, using any of the usual wait methods of Task and so on. After the awaiting, you can do all the asserts as usual. For example, using MSTest:

[TestMethod]
public void MyTestMethod()
{
    ...
    Task<MyResultClass> task = objectUnderTest.MyAsyncMethod(...);
    // Make anything that waits for the method to end
    MyResultClass result = task.Result;

    // Make the assertions
    Assert.IsNotNull(result);
    ...
}