android - When to save data to database, onPause() or onStop()?

Question

I know this question has been asked a million times, I myself though that I already knew the answer and that the correct one was that the only guaranteed call is to onPause(), so you should save your data there.

However, in many places of android documentation they always suggest not doing heavy work (such as writing data in database) in the onPause() method as it will delay the transition between the activities.

According to Android Developer Guide in Table 1

onPause(): This method is typically used to commit unsaved changes to persistent data, stop animations and other things that may be consuming CPU, and so on. It should do whatever it does very quickly, because the next activity will not be resumed until it returns.

Killable: YES

Then according to Android Developer Reference Guide in the similar table.

It says the same thing but:

Killable: Pre-HONEYCOMB

And they add a little note that says:

Be aware that these semantics will change slightly between applications targeting platforms starting with HONEYCOMB vs. those targeting prior platforms. Starting with Honeycomb, an application is not in the killable state until its onStop() has returned. This impacts when onSaveInstanceState(Bundle) may be called (it may be safely called after onPause() and allows and application to safely wait until onStop() to save persistent state.

---

Killable

Note the "Killable" column in the above table -- for those methods that are marked as being killable, after that method returns the process hosting the activity may killed by the system at any time without another line of its code being executed.

FOR POST-HONEYCOMB (i dont care about earlier versions): So, is it OK to assume that any Android device (including different ROMS) will ensure a call to onStop on the activity? And this is the best place to make any time consuming storage writing of the App?

Note: This is extremely confusing as most answers here, sites, books, and even online android tests take as a correct answer that you should save it in onPause and NOT in onStop.

Answer 1

When to save data to database, onPause() or onStop()?

Either. They are nearly identical, particularly on Android 3.0+.

If the activity that is taking over the foreground is a typical full-screen activity, so that the earlier activity is no longer visible, onPause() and onStop() will be called in rapid succession.

If the activity that is taking over the foreground is themed to be more like a dialog, where the earlier activity is still visible, onPause() will be called, but not onStop(), until such time as the activity is no longer visible (e.g., user now presses HOME).

Most apps aren't worried about the "themed to be more like a dialog" scenario, in which case onPause() and onStop() are called one right after the next, and you can fork your background thread to save your data in whichever of those makes sense to you.

However, in many places of android documentation they always suggest not doing heavy work (such as writing data in database) in the onPause() method as it will delay the transition between the activities.

The same is true of onStop(), as both of those methods are called on the main application thread.

So, is it OK to assume that any Android device (including different ROMS) will ensure a call to onStop on the activity?

Both onPause() and onStop() will have the same characteristics from the standpoint of process termination. Either both should be called (normal case) or neither will be called (e.g., you crash, the battery pops out the back of the phone).

And this is the best place to make any time consuming storage writing of the App?

Either onPause() or onStop() are fine places to trigger the work, done on a background thread, to persist your data. If you prefer to do that work in onStop(), you are absolutely welcome to do so. Personally, I'm an onPause() kind of guy.