android - Capturing audio sent to Google's speech recognition server

Question

to recognize speech by Google server, I use SpeechRecognizer class in combination with RecognitionListener as suggested in Stephan's answer to this question . In addition, I try to capture the audio signal being recognized by using onBufferReceived() callback from RecognitionListener like:

byte[] sig = new byte[500000] ;
int sigPos = 0 ;
...
public void onBufferReceived(byte[] buffer) {
  System.arraycopy(buffer, 0, sig, sigPos, buffer.length) ;
  sigPos += buffer.length ;
}
...

This seems working fine, except when SpeechRecognizer fails connecting to the Google server, when a chunk of audio is not copied into the above-mentioned sig array, and an HTTP connection time-out exception is thrown. SpeechRecognizer eventually connects to the Google server and recognition results indicate that a complete audio signal was received; only the sig array is missing some audio chunk(s).

Does anybody experience the same problem? Any hint for solution? Thank you!

Answer 1

I tend to say this might be a inconsistency in the behavior of the recognition service, maybe even a bug in the Android version you use. However, the documentation states, that it is not guaranteed that this method is called so it would fit into the specification. What I noticed so far is the following (on Android 2.3.4): I get the bytes while recording, but if there is for example a SocketTimeout it tries to resend the data to the server after some time, but without calling onBufferReceived again for the same data. The code used to test that was the same as the one you have linked in your posting.

Why do you think some chunks are missing from the audio you received in the method? If it were only a few chunks missing, it might even be the case, that the recognition worked although those chunks were missing.